Rachel Corrie, the bias of facts and when truths become lies

Saturday marked the 10th anniversary of the death of a young woman standing in front of a tractor which was bulldozing a home. The bulldozer operator ran over the woman. The cause of death was described as “by pressure on the chest (mechanicalasphyxiation) with fractures of the ribs and vertebrae of the dorsal spinal column and scapulas, and tear wounds in the right lung with hemorrhaging of thepleural cavities.” Authorities later cleared the operator of any wrong doing…100604_Rachel_Corrie

These are the facts of Rachel Corrie’s death 10 years years ago. They are facts, but I have purposely left out other facts to illustrate a point. I have said in this forum that facts are not truth, and even truths can become lies when filtered through the bias of the human heart. A collection of facts may be truth or through omission, facts can absolutely portray a lie. That is what I did with the first paragraph. There are fcts. Keys facts are omitted to illustrate a point.

When human rights-all human rights-regardless of religion, nationality, gender, sexuality and race fails to be the stndard upon which all things are judged in society, judgement is at the mercy of arbitrary and ever changing filters.

Through news, nationalism and even religion, the words Palestine, Gaza and Palestinian takes on a much different dimension. All too aften they evoke images perpetuated by governments and media. But even images evoke a certain bias, but those biases become our individual crime against real truths about humanity. Those biases weaken us against the purveyors of war and violence and division and hatred. It draws us among their ranks.

The bulldozing of homes becomes the regrettable response to a nation and people who feel eternally victimized and besieged by Gazan and pPslestinian terrorists. This is the narrative promoted by those governments and their media. Is that the truth, however? It is, arguably to some, but when held against the standard of universal human rights, that assumed truth becomes a lie.

Rachel Corrie, a 23 year old college student from Olympia Washington and others went to Rafah Gaza where she was killed in 2003. An Israeli court denied, despite video and eyewitness testimony that the bulldozer drove over Corrie, concluding that she was “struck by a hard object, most probably a slab of concrete which was moved or slid down while the mound of earth which she was standing behind was moved.”

A witness, Joseph Carr, recalled that the “bulldozer driver and co-operator could clearly see her. Despite this, the driver continued forward, which caused her to fall back, out of view of the driver. He continued forward, and she tried to scoot back, but was quickly pulled underneath the bulldozer.” corrie7

A British activist, Tom Dale, also witnessed the incident. “Rachel could not have been more visible: standing, on a clear day, in the open ground, wearing a high visibility vest. On that day, she had been in the presence of the Caterpillar D9 bulldozers used by the Israeli army for some hours. She was standing in front of the home of a young family which was under threat of demolition by a bulldozer. Many homes were demolished in such a way at that time, and Rachel was seeking to protect her friends, with whom she had lived.
Whatever one thinks about the visibility from a D9 bulldozer, it is inconceivable that at some point the driver did not see her, given the distance from which he approached, while she stood, unmoving, in front of it. As I told the court, just before she was crushed, Rachel briefly stood on top of the rolling mound of earth which had gathered in front of the bulldozer: her head was above the level of the blade, and just a few meters from the driver.”corrie_bulldozer_1852647_610x438

Corrie spent time with Rafah municipal workers who were struggling to repair a well damaged by Israeli bulldozers. It was one of two wells that accounted for more than half of the drinking water to the city in the desert region. The damage to the well resulted in severe water restrictions to the city. The Israeli’s routinly fired on workers attempting to repair the wells. Israeli soldiers frequently fired on homes as they were being bulldozed, resulting in some 240 deaths, including 78 children. Israeli regulations require that armored personnel carriers direct the bulldozers to their targets. An Israeli officer later testified that Corrie and others had tried for hours to stop the demolition, which took place under his command. Though it may be argued the bulldozer operator may have lost sight of Corrie at some point, it is clear that the Israeli army who was directing him knew she was there.

This piece is not about Israel or Palestine, or necessarily about Corrie, but rather the weight each of us brings to news stories. When we a hear descriptive word, what is the assumption and bias that we bring to that word? How do each of us come to the words Israeli, Palestinian, Jew, Muslim, Activist, Student, Gaza? There is a history in each of those words, and that history bears an undeniable weight upon each of us. But are we slaves to that history, or do we have the will and ability to challenge those histories? Are we filters for the news and the propaganda of governments, or are we judges of them? And as judges, what is the standard? Is it tribal loyalties, or human loyalties?

Given that, how might you have come to this story? I might have written the first paragraph this way:3876b419e4b1b7a9ce3e0635ce1c5bc8

Saturday marked the 10th anniversary of the death of a American activist Rachel Corrie who attempted to stop the illegal bulldozing of an innocent Palestinian pharmacist’s home. Samir Nasralla was forced to flee from the home with his family to join some 17,000 Palestinians made homeless this way between 2000 and 2004. The land was being cleared for Israeli settlements. Despite being acknowledged by the bulldozer operator, the woman, wearing bright orange safety vest and appealing for mercy on the family with a bullhorn, was run over twice by the bulldozer. The demolition proceeded despite the dying woman still laying on the ground nearby. The cause of death was described as “by pressure on the chest (mechanicalasphyxiation) with fractures of the ribs and vertebrae of the dorsal spinal column and scapulas, and tear wounds in the right lung with hemorrhaging of the pleural cavities.” Authorities later cleared the operator of any wrong doing…

Catch 900poundgorilla’s WC Turck and Brian Murray each Sunday 8-9am only on Our Town with Mike Sanders, at Chicago’s Progressive Talk, WCPT AM and FM, and streaming online. Our Town is sponsored by HORA USA, at http://www.HORAusa.com. HORA is an evolutionary meditative practice for the whole body and mind. Take the next step in your personal evolution at http://www.HORAusa.com.

Friend us on Facebook at Revolution and Beer. And if you have a cause to champion, please let us know as we work to become the grassroots support network for Chicago Activists and community organizers.

Catch the beer of the week review with 900poundgorilla’s WC Turck and Brian Murray each Sunday 8-9am only on Our Town, at Chicago’s Progressive Talk, WCPT AM and FM, and streaming online. Friend us on Facebook at Revolution and Beer. And find all of the great beers we review each week at Louis Glunz Beer Inc., http://www.glunzbeers.com

About 900poundgorilla

W.C. Turck is a Chicago playwright and the author of four widely acclaimed books.His latest is "The Last Man," a prophetic novel of a world ruled by a single corporation. His first novel, "Broken: One Soldier's Unexpected Journey Home," was reccommended by the National Association of Mental Health Institutes. His 2009 Memoir, "Everything for Love" chronicled the genocide in Bosnia and the siege of Sarajevo. His third book "Burn Down the Sky" is published exclusively on Amazon Kindle. It was in Sarajevo at the height of the siege where he met and married his wife, writer and Artist Ana Turck. FOX NEWS, ABC, CBS News, the Chicago Tribune and The Joliet Herald covered their reunion after the war. He helped organized relief into Rwanda during the 1994 genocide. Turck has been a guest on WMAQ-TV, WLS in Chicago, WCPT, WBBM radio, National Public Radio, Best Of the Left and the Thom Hartmann show. He has spoken frequently on Human Rights, Genocide and Nationalism. In 2011, his play in support of the Occupy Movement, "Occupy My Heart-a revolutionary Christmas Carol" recieved national media attention and filled theaters to capacity across Chicago. He remains an activist to the cause of human rights and international peace. View all posts by 900poundgorilla

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: